I know that hobbit comparisons are supposed to be insulting, but remember that the hobbits win... and if you're against the hobbits then who does that make you? Walter Russell Meade writes that after decades spent mocking him the Left is just beginning to realize that Clarence Thomas is approaching their Mount Doom.

There are few articles of faith as firmly fixed in the liberal canon as the belief that Clarence Thomas is, to put it as bluntly as many liberals do, a dunce and a worm. Twenty years of married life have not erased the conventional liberal view of his character etched by Anita Hill's testimony at his confirmation hearings. Not only does the liberal mind perceive him as a disgusting lump of ungoverned sexual impulse; he is seen as an intellectual cipher. Thomas' silence during oral argument before the Supreme Court is taken as obvious evidence that he has nothing to say and is perhaps a bit intimidated by the verbal fireworks exchanged by the high profile lawyers and his more, ahem, 'qualified' colleagues.

At most liberals have long seen Thomas as the Sancho Panza to Justice Antonio Scalia's Don Quixote, Tonto to his Lone Ranger. No, says Toobin: the intellectual influence runs the other way. Thomas is the consistently clear and purposeful theorist that history will remember as an intellectual pioneer; Scalia the less clear-minded colleague who is gradually following in Thomas' tracks.

If Toobin's revionist take is correct, (and I defer to his knowledge of the direction of modern constitutional thought) it means that liberal America has spent a generation mocking a Black man as an ignorant fool, even as constitutional scholars stand in growing amazement at the intellectual audacity, philosophical coherence and historical reflection embedded in his judicial work.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Clarence Thomas Approaches Mount Doom.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.mwilliams.info/mt5/tb-confess.cgi/7872



Email blogmasterofnoneATgmailDOTcom for text link and key word rates.

Site Info